Search...

Volume 7 - Issue 20 (2026-11-20)


Volume 7 - Issue 20 (2026-11-20)

Effectiveness of Prehospital Triage Tools in Identifying Critically Ill and Injured Patients: A Systematic Review

1- Researcher: Raed Saeed Zaghwan

2- Researcher: Abdulrahman Abdullah Mohammed AL Mudawi

3- Researcher: Ebtihal Ali Saleh AlHussain

4- Researcher: Aseel Mohammad Al Aboudi

5- Researcher: Abdullah Sami Ahmed Almoshaikeh

6- Researcher: Mohammed Abdulrahim Khalifah Alqulayti

7- Researcher: Abdullah Faisal Aljishi

8- Researcher: Abdullah Owaidh Alharbi

9- Researcher: Abdulmuhsen Mohammed Najem

10- Researcher: Adnan Ateeq Marzuq Alharbi

11- Researcher: Naeem Salah Saleh Alhejaili


Researcher Institutional Affiliation:

Emergency Medical Services - Saudi Red Crescent Authority

Abstract:

Background: Prehospital triage tools guide ambulance clinicians in identifying patients at risk of time-critical deterioration or major traumatic injury. Early warning scores, physiologic indices, trauma field triage protocols and condition-specific tools differ in intended population, thresholds and reference standards.

Aim: To evaluate the diagnostic and prognostic performance of prehospital triage tools for detecting critically ill and injured patients, and to examine trade-offs between undertriage and overtriage.

Methods: An evidence-informed systematic-review draft was prepared using a narrative comparison of 16 identifiable original investigations, spanning adult general medical, infectious, respiratory and trauma cohorts. PubMed and publisher records informed the evidence map. A PRISMA 2020 example flow beginning with 395 records and ending with 16 included studies is supplied for subsequent replacement with audit-supported counts. The JBI Diagnostic Test Accuracy checklist provides the appraisal framework; the provisional matrix reflects only information apparent in the accessible reports or abstracts.

Results: Validation studies found highly variable performance across settings. In a prospective field-triage cohort, the national trauma guideline had 66.2% sensitivity and 87.8% specificity for serious injury; sensitivity fell among older adults. A Swedish ambulance study reported 73% sensitivity for time-sensitive conditions using RETTS-A compared with 37% for NEWS and 35% for NEWS2, but with lower specificity. In a Spanish multicenter sample, NEWS2 achieved an AUROC of 0.891 for 48-hour mortality; other cohorts showed more modest discrimination. A UK major-trauma validation cohort demonstrated marked sensitivity–specificity trade-offs between alternative decision tools. These observations describe predictive accuracy; they do not establish that deploying a particular score alone reduces mortality.

Conclusion: Prehospital triage tools can support structured risk recognition, but no instrument consistently optimizes sensitivity, specificity, clinical feasibility and destination decisions across every patient group. Threshold selection, clinical judgment, age-related undertriage and prospective implementation evaluation remain essential.

Keywords

Emergency medical services; prehospital triage; critically ill; major trauma; NEWS2; RETTS-A; early warning scores; undertriage; sensitivity; specificity; JBI; PRISMA 2020.,

Pages: 702-719