1- Researcher: Azzam Mohammed Alqurashi
2- Researcher: Bandar Dakhilallah Alharthi
3- Researcher: Sultan Abdullah Althomali
4- Researcher: Fayez Ali Althomali
5- Researcher: Rakan Mansour Alhousseni
6- Researcher: Ahmed Mahmoud Altowairqi
7- Researcher: Helal Saud Alqurashi
8- Researcher: Mansour Farhan Algethami
Saudi Red Crescent Authority - Saudi Arabia
Background. International mass gatherings bring together participants who differ in language, cultural expectations and familiarity with host-country emergency systems. In prehospital care, language discordance may undermine emergency call-taking, symptom assessment, consent, clinical instructions and interagency coordination. The Hajj pilgrimage offers a particularly relevant setting in which crowd density and multilingual patient encounters occur simultaneously.
Objective. To examine published evidence on the relationship of language and cultural barriers to prehospital emergency care access, communication, safety and operational efficiency during international mass gatherings, with particular attention to Hajj and transferability from other EMS systems.
Methods. This manuscript follows the structure of the supplied systematic-review reference and develops an evidence-grounded narrative synthesis of 11 identifiable primary publications. Four are Hajj-setting investigations and seven provide related prehospital/dispatch evidence from other countries. Studies were grouped by setting and outcome; design-specific JBI appraisal domains were mapped. Because original database exports and a complete screening log were not supplied, an auditable PRISMA study-selection count and final study-level risk-of-bias ratings are not asserted.
Results. Hajj studies identify language discordance, difficulty obtaining histories, crowd access constraints, and culturally sensitive clinical interactions as operational concerns. Evidence from other EMS settings demonstrates delayed dispatch allocation during language-discordant calls, missed information in cardiac-arrest calls, and greater reported preparedness after training. A small nonrandomized translation-app study reported better paramedic-rated communication. These findings do not establish a pooled effect on Hajj mortality or transport outcomes.
Conclusion. Communication support should be incorporated into mass-gathering EMS design through multilingual access routes, rapidly available professional interpretation, culturally responsive training and measurable handover standards. Prospective Hajj-specific studies are needed to establish whether these approaches improve objective patient outcomes.
الكلمات المفتاحية
mass gatherings; Hajj; emergency medical services; prehospital care; language barriers; cultural competence; interpreters; patient safety; systematic review.,الصفحات: 831 -846